Shi’a History and Identity

Esoteric Imam Ali carrying his own funeral coffin as witnessed by his sons Imams Hassan and Hussein, from a Falnama of Ja'far al-Sadiq, ca. 1550sShi’ism is much more than simply a denomination or sect of Islam beginning with the early dispute over the successorship of the Prophet Muhammad in 11/632. As long as there has been Islam, Shi’ism has been a part of the larger Muslim body politic and provided its own theological, legal, mystical, and philosophical traditions and worldview. Shi’ism is a major contributor to world culture and civilization with a rich and varied denominational landscape internal to the faith (including Twelver, Isma’ili, Zaydi, Alevi, Alawite, and other branches) and a vast history encompassing various novel political projects, social movements, and intellectual contributions across the Middle East, North Africa, Central and South Asia, and beyond. In this research focus, the Project on Shi'ism and Global Affairs looks to explore how the history of Shi’ism has impacted contemporary dynamics across the globe and how the legacy of diverse Shi’a institutions and historical memory contributes to modern debates of identity, institutions, and ideology.

Photo caption: Esoteric Imam Ali carrying his own funeral coffin as witnessed by his sons Imams Hassan and Hussein, from a Falnama of Ja'far al-Sadiq, ca. 1550s

The Hidden Imam and the End of Time: A Primer on the Mahdi, Islamic Theology, and Global Politics
Payam Mohseni and Mohammad Sagha. 6/2022. The Hidden Imam and the End of Time: A Primer on the Mahdi, Islamic Theology, and Global Politics.Abstract


For hundreds of millions of Muslims around the world, including in the West, the Hidden Imam is at the heart of Islam. While those with some background in the study of the faith may have heard of this belief, its core centrality in the Islamic tradition is generally not recognized or properly understood. To address the gap in knowledge on this issue, the Project on Shi’ism and Global Affairs at Harvard University’s Weatherhead Center has produced the present report, entitled The Hidden Imam and the End of Time: A Primer on the Mahdi, Islamic Theology, and Global Politics, to raise awareness on the concept, meaning, and significance of the Hidden Imam for scholars, policymakers, and broader public audiences alike.

In particular, this primer answers five pertinent questions of significance on this subject relevant to religion and global affairs: 1) Who is the Hidden Imam?; 2) Do Sunni Muslims also believe in the Hidden Imam?; 3) How is the Imam different from the Caliphate?; 4) Why is the Hidden Imam considered central to Islam by many Muslims?; and 5) How does the belief in the Hidden Imam impact Muslim social and political affairs?

Authors: 
Payam Mohseni (Harvard University) and Mohammad Sagha (University of Chicago)

To read and download the report, click here.

*Updated Report (June 30, 2022): This version includes the correction that, according to mainstream Musta'li Ismaili belief, there is currently a line of Hidden Imams descended  from Imam Tayyib who went into occultation in the twelfth century CE. The original report noted that Imam Tayyib was a currently living Hidden Imam.

A Genealogy of Conflict: An Interior View of the War in Yemen
Marieke Brandt. 3/11/2021. “A Genealogy of Conflict: An Interior View of the War in Yemen.” Cambridge, MA: Harvard University WCFIA Project on Shi'ism and Global Affairs.Abstract
Over the past years, the war in Yemen developed many internal and external dynamics. The focus of international observers and the media is often more on its regional political contexts, thereby largely disregarding the local dynamics of this conflict whose roots go back far into the history of Yemen. This lecture gives an insight into the local history of this conflict, with a special focus on the roots of Zaydi revivalism in highland Yemen and the emergence of the Zaydi “Ḥūthīs” (also called Ansar Allah), as well as interlinked tribal, socio-historical, and political dynamics in Yemen that explain the Ḥūthī conflict’s onset persistence and expansion.
Diversity and Unity in Transnational Shi’ism: Proceedings of the International Symposium at Harvard University (April 5-8, 2021)
Ali Asani, Payam Mohseni, and Mohammad Sagha. 12/2021. Diversity and Unity in Transnational Shi’ism: Proceedings of the International Symposium at Harvard University (April 5-8, 2021). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Weatherhead Center for International Affairs.Abstract

The Project on Shi’ism and Global Affairs is proud to publish a report, “Diversity and Unity in Transnational Shi’ism (PDF),” based on the proceedings of an international symposium hosted at Harvard University in April, 2021. The symposium brought together interdisciplinary voices from across various interpretations of Shi'a Islam in both contemporary and historical contexts with leading scholars in the field who study the diversity of Shi’a thought and communities across denominational lines including Zaydi, Ismaili, Alevi, Alawite, Bektashi, and Twelver Ja'fari Islam among others. This report includes the edited remarks of the expert participants in the symposium.

While individual works and scholars have focused on distinct Shi'a groups in specific countries or world regions, less attention has been paid to addressing diversity within Shi’ism from a comparative perspective or thinking about how to approach the subject of intra-Shi’a dialogue rather than interfaith dialogue more broadly. This is all the more important as the historical and contemporary legacy of Shi'a Islam is extraordinarily rich and truly global in reach.

The symposium thus fostered a larger dialogue on the historical relationship between Shi’a groups, intellectual and scholarly conversations between them, and contemporary areas of convergence and diversity that intersect with transnational Shi'a groups ranging from Twelvers in Iran, Iraq and Pakistan, to Zaydis in the Arabian Peninsula, to Isma'ilis in Tajikistan and India, to Bektashi Shi'as in the Balkans, and to Shi'a diaspora communities in the West and beyond. 

Read or download the report (PDF).

 

The Prophet's Heir: The Life of Ali ibn Abi Talib
Hassan Abbas. 3/2021. The Prophet's Heir: The Life of Ali ibn Abi Talib. New Haven: Yale University Press. Publisher's VersionAbstract

Ali ibn Abi Talib is arguably the single most important spiritual and intellectual authority in Islam after prophet Mohammad. Through his teachings and leadership as fourth caliph, Ali nourished Islam. But Muslims are divided on whether he was supposed to be Mohammad’s political successor—and he continues to be a polarizing figure in Islamic history.
 
Hassan Abbas provides a nuanced, compelling portrait of this towering yet divisive figure and the origins of sectarian division within Islam. Abbas reveals how, after Mohammad, Ali assumed the spiritual mantle of Islam to spearhead the movement that the prophet had led. While Ali’s teachings about wisdom, justice, and selflessness continue to be cherished by both Shia and Sunni Muslims, his pluralist ideas have been buried under sectarian agendas and power politics. Today, Abbas argues, Ali’s legacy and message stands against that of ISIS, Al-Qaeda, and Taliban.

Read more about the book here.

Transmitting and Transforming Traditions: Salman Ahmad and Sufi Rock
Ali Asani. 7/2019. “Transmitting and Transforming Traditions: Salman Ahmad and Sufi Rock.” In Sufism East and West: Mystical Islam and Cross-Cultural Exchange in the Modern World, edited by Jamal Malik and Saeed Zarrabi-Zadeh, Pp. 259–272. Brill. Publisher's VersionAbstract

Historically, South Asia’s many literary traditions have provided both the structure and the idiom for Muslims across a broad spectrum of ideological persuasions to express and transmit their ideas. As is well known, Sufis affiliated with different tariqas have commonly employed genres of vernacular folk poetry as a means of elucidating and popularizing mystical ideas. Over the last century, thanks to a variety of intricately related set of factors such as the revolution in media technology, globalization and the spread of popular western culture and the rise of religiously based nationalisms, the form, content and context of South Asian Muslim devotional expressions have been radically transformed. This chapter explores the emergence of Sufi Rock, a new genre of Muslim devotional expression that has become increasingly popular in South Asia, particularly Pakistan. A genre which fuses western rock music with traditional Sufi poetry and imagery, Sufi Rock is commonly associated with one of its earliest exponents, Salman Ahmad, a guitarist and vocalist in one of South Asia’s biggest rock band, Junoon. The chapter explores Salman’s role in the emergence of Sufi Rock, specifically with reference to his professional development as a musician and spiritual development as a Muslim who deeply identifies with Sufism.

2024 Mar 05

The Consciousness of Being: An Introduction to Imamology

4:00pm

Location: 

Harvard Divinity School - Location TBA

Imamology 2

Shi’a Muslims consider the Prophet Muhammad and the Imams that follow him not only as political and spiritual leaders but also the center of creation, the cosmos, and consciousness. Who is the figure of the Imam, and how can we understand the station and function of such a pivotal concept as the Imam in Shi’a Islam? This workshop will explore the philosophical and epistemological approaches to understanding the nature, function of authority, and legitimacy of the Imam in Shi'a Islam. The lecture, by Dr. Payam Mohseni (Harvard), will also briefly cover aspects of the pluralism and various approaches toward the Imam throughout various Shi’a traditions.... Read more about The Consciousness of Being: An Introduction to Imamology

2023 Oct 05

ALI: Introducing the Imam Ali Research Track at Harvard Divinity School's Project on Shi'ism & Global Affairs

5:00pm to 6:30pm

Location: 

Swartz Hall - 120 James Room East - 45 Francis Ave, Cambridge MA 02138

ALI

Abstract:

Harvard Divinity School's Project on Shi'ism and Global Affairs is proud to announce the launch of a new research track on the Life and Legacy of Imam Ali, generously sponsored by the Jaffer Family Foundation of New York. The figure of Ali ibn Abi Talib has been simultaneously enigmatic and manifest throughout Islamic history. As the key companion, cousin, and son-in-law to the Prophet Muhammad, Ali occupied a paramount role from the very origins of Islam. Both the first Shi’a Imam–and progenitor of the line of imamate–and fourth Sunni Caliph, the legacy, memory, and centrality of Ali is a key pillar of Shi’a and Sunni Islam. His embodiment of justice, leadership, and esoteric knowledge continue to form a bedrock of Islamic ideals. Virtually all Sufi orders in Islam, Sunni and Shi’a alike, trace their lineage to this recognized fountainhead of wisdom. This panel discussion brings together scholars and specialists to discuss the field of study surrounding Imam Ali–in the past, present, and future. Open to the public both in-person and online (hybrid).... Read more about ALI: Introducing the Imam Ali Research Track at Harvard Divinity School's Project on Shi'ism & Global Affairs